Pur vs Brita vs Zero | Best Water Filter Pitcher According to Reddit

I may receive a commission for purchases made through product links on this page, but I always stand by my opinions and endorsements!

When I’m trying to get information on the best equipment or product, I almost always go to Reddit first so I can find out what real people have to say.

I recently did this with a water filter pitcher.

So what are the best water filter pitcher according to Reddit? Here’s what I found after going through tons of threads on r/eatcheapAndHealthy, r/BuyItForLife, and more. Below I compare four popular brands Pur vs Brita vs Zero vs Clearly.

On Reddit, things people consider when choosing the best water filter are. 

• Tastes of Filtered water 
• Design and Durability 
• Initial costs and cost of replacing filters
• Capacity and speed
• Ability to remove many Contaminants 

Best Water Filter Reddit: Pur vs Brita vs Zero vs Cleary

ClearlyFiltered: Most Popular Filter Pitcher on Reddit

Clearly Water filter pitcher is actually one of the few pitchers that actually remove fluoride and radiological impurities. This is a very big deal for most people. If you’re keen enough, you will see most pitcher brands claim to remove chlorine, heavy metals, and other chemicals, but not many remove fluoride.

If research about the effects of fluoride on the human brain, you will understand where removing fluoride is so important to a lot of people that invest in a water filter pitchers.

Although Clearly is a bit pricey compared to other cheap brands, it makes it up by the long-lasting filter life. Every single filter will give you 100 gallons of drinking water. This is significantly higher than other pitchers like zero water with giving as low as 15- 20 gallons.

With Clearly Water Filter Pitcher You Get…

The Clearly filter pitcher design is great. It has a clear body which very sleek. And refilling it is easy because of the big mouth on top.

PUR Filter Water Filter Review

If you need something that will last longer, without a doubt, try out  Pur CR-6000 7 cup water filter pitcher. It’s built with ease of maneuvering in mind.

In fact, the ease of handling is one of the most common advantages that was cited by most of the people who preferred Pur instead of  Brita. The opinion was that Brita was cracky to handle while Pur is easier to maneuver. 

When it comes to the removal of contaminants Pur uses activated carbon filters which are designed to remove pathogens and chemicals such as chlorine, chloramine, mercury, and pharmaceuticals. PUR uses activated carbon which is made from treated coconut shells with high absorption capacity.  

PUR is certified by NSF to remove cryptosporidium and giardia. Lots of buyers have said that they really loved that the PUR LED 11 Cup Water Filtration Pitcher is made using food-grade materials, and it’s made using BPA free materials.

And because it uses a 3 stage filtration process it’s able to get rid of contaminants which other filter pitchers can’t like debris. The 3 stage filtration process is able to improve the test to a great extent. The 3-stage filtration process is 

1. Tight mesh- It’s used to remove large debris from water such as rocks.
2. Activated carbon- After the water passes through the fine mesh it comes into contact with activated carbon which is made from coconut shell which has a porous surface. Activated carbon absorbs contaminants from water. 
3. Ion Exchange- The final stage is ion-exchange which gets rid of limescale and improves the taste. 

The PUR LED is large enough to handle 11 cups of water at a time which is higher than most pitchers. Let us jump in and look at the pros and cons of PUR LED 11 Cup Water Filtration Pitcher.

Best Brita Pitcher According to Reddit

Brita every day stands because of its high quality in comparison to the other models. With this fantastic water pitcher, you’ll enjoy freshly filtered water. This pitcher model is large and transparent, and thus it is easy to pour and refill.

The BPA free Brita filter eliminates chlorine taste and, contaminants like copper, mercury, and cadmium scums found in tap water to give you a cleaner and tasty water.

We need to mention that the Brita Everyday model has an incredible filter indicator that notifies you when your water filter is due for replacement. For this reason, you can make optimum use of this pitcher.

Similarly, it features short, ergonomic handle. As such, is it easy to pour when the pitcher full? When it comes to the filter replacements, we recommend you change Brita filters after every 40 gallons, roughly months for the average household, for the pitcher’s optimal performance.

2. Brita Metro Pitcher with 1 Filter, 5 Cup

Brita Metro is a small, plastic water filtration pitcher that is easy to pour and refill. You’ll note that it is 9.8” in height and 4.45″; width while it weighs 1.39 pounds. For this reason, it will fit well on refrigerator shelves due to this efficient space.

On the other hand, this model reduces chlorine, copper, mercury, zinc, and cadmium impurities found in tap water to give you clean and great tasting

Unlike other models, this features an electronic filter indicator for optimum performance. The automatic indicator will notify you when the filter is due for replacement

Also, this Brita water filter can replace 300 standard 16 oz. water bottles. It will, therefore, save you money and reduce your plastic waste. Thus the use of this filter pitcher improves environmental preservation.

It is important to note that you will need to change Brita standard filters after every 40 gallons, around two months, for the average household to get optimal performance. With this kind of maintenance, it will last twice longer than the Zerowater filter.

3. Brita Large 10 Cup Water Filter Pitcher 

As I was researching Brita Grand water pitcher reviews, I noticed that quite a few people complained about that Brita almost always leaks fragments of carbon into the unfiltered water chamber. Having said that, you should know that the substance that looks like charcoal is perfectly safe. 

The Brita Grand Water pitcher is available in a variety of colors -this is great because you can choose the model that fits your kitchen’s design.

The filter is made using BPA free materials. It’s one of the few pitchers that comes with an electronic indicator to notify you when you needed to change filters. 

When it comes to removing contaminants, It’s very effective. It uses an activated carbon made from coconut shells. It has the ability to remove chlorine and heavy metals. Brita Grand water 10 cup water tastes better because it’s more alkaline. 

The dimensions are 10.5″ X 11″ X 4.5″. When it comes to the life of the filters, each filter will give about 40 gallons of filtered water before the indicator light tells to replace the filters. It’s fair to say Brita Grand water pitcher is among the most popular filter on the market today. Lets now dive in and look at the pros and cons. 

⇒Recommended Post: Best Brita  Water Filter Pitcher 

ZeroWater 8 Cup Round Pitcher Review

As you know, there are lots of water filter pitchers in the market, but ZeroWater Filter Pitcher is in a class of its own when it comes to the ability to removes contaminants from water. It removes all the dissolved substance from water. When you buy this pitcher, it comes with a tester for measuring the total dissolved substance in water. 

ZeroWater filters use a 5-stage filtration process that removes almost all the dissolved substance. The five processes are: 

1. The first step is a fine filter screen for removing debris in the water. This filter only deals with solid contaminants but not dissolved chemicals. 
2. After removing solid debris,  the second step is a special filter foam that removes additional suspended solids. 
3. The third stage involves water passing through multiple layers of activated carbons which removes contaminants such as chlorine, chloramines, pesticides, and herbicides. 
4. Next step, water passes through ion exchange through the resin. At this stage, inorganic chemicals such as fluoride. At this stage, limescale is removed.
5. The final stage is another fine screen filter for removing suspended solids. 

You might be wondering what are the downsides, for sure, this pitcher carries a hefty price tag when you add the cost of filters. Although the startup cost is not that high, the cost of filters is on the higher side.  With that out of the way, let us look at the pro and cons. 

What to consider when buying a water filter pitchers

1.Target Contaminants

Notably, no one filter does it all. The majority of the pitchers eliminate contaminants that leave a bad taste and odor, such as chlorine, zinc, and hydrogen sulfide.

Generally, only a few pitchers can remove lead. Only one pitcher in our current review can remove lead. If a pitcher does filter out the lead or other contaminants such as volatile organic compounds and heavy metals, its packaging should cite a separate certification mark for each.

2. Pitcher Size

Brita water pitchers have a maximum capacity of 10 cups of roughly 0.6 gallons. And With a 10-cup size, your family can drink filtered water anytime, yet you refill the pitcher less often.

3. Filter Life

Typically, the lifespan of a filter will depend on the level of contamination present in your water. The manufacturer usually estimates your tap water is in reasonable condition.

Although Brita pitchers produce clean and tasty water, the manufacturer instructions, on the other hand, state that you should change the filters once every two months; as such, their filters are not long-lasting.

It is important to note that with an average consumption of 2 gallons per day, you can change the filters once every 20 days.

Also, Brita water filter pitchers come with a single filter cartridge, so you might have to make a new investment after replacement

Best of all, Brita models rely on a light sensor to keep track of filter usage. The filter replacement sensor turns yellow when the filters approach their maximum filtering capacity, and red when the filter is due for replacement.

4. Pitcher Shape

The majority of Brita pitchers come with a locking lid, and this prevents spillage. Also, it makes it easy to pour out and refill water. Even better, the pitchers are transparent.

5. Features

Brita filter pitcher has a capacity of between 5 and 10 cups, which is enough for the average household.

All the Brita filter pitcher features a sticker indicator, which lets you know when it’s time to change the filters.

The water filter pitchers can process up to 40 gallons, on average,  enough to last you a couple of months.

6. Materials

Most of Brita has a plastic body, making them affordable and lightweight.

It’s essential to note that not all plastics are of low quality because low quality plastics can be a health hazard, besides such material may percolate chemicals into the water that interfere with your hormone levels.

Brita filter pitchers use food-grade plastics and bisphenol-A-free materials.

7. Colors

The Brita Pitchers are available in blue, green, white and coffee black. You’ll have the luxury of choice to match your homes’ faucets

8. Price

Generally, an average filter of up to 40 gallons will cost you around 15 dollars for a three-pack filter set.

We need to mention that the Brita filters model has the latest one known as Brita Longlast filter that can deliver up to 120 gallons of water. Although it will cost you more, you’ll reduce the hassle of changing the filter frequently

Reasons to Have a Water Purifier Pitcher

1. Removing contaminants

Water purifier pitcher effectively filters out harmful contaminants present in your tap water. These contaminants have devastating effects both on your skin, hair, and home appliances. Thus, it is essential to prevent these contaminants from getting into your body to avoid dry and itchy skin, dry hair, or other hard water-related issues.

2. Ease of Use

Similarly, a water purifier pitcher is easy to use and it requires little or no maintenance apart from replacing the filter every few months. Better still, with a water purifier pitcher, you’ll not require any installation. Also, this product conveniently fits in most refrigerators.

3. Affordability

Undeniably, the water purifier pitcher is famous due to its affordability. This option will cost you less than the conventional filtration options. Mostly, filter pitchers can eliminate your need for bottled water because they produce clean and taste the water. A pitcher can take the place of thousands of water bottles; this makes the product eco-friendly.

4. Great-Tasting Drinking Water

Lastly, the water filter pitcher provides clean and better-tasting drinking water by reducing bacterial contaminants and chlorine. One of the most significant setbacks about tap water is its bad taste and smell. While bottled water may appear like a better option, when you consider in the cost, you will realize that water filter pitcher is the most cost-effective method of water purification.

Frequently Asked Questions 

ABOUT LEON SMITH Leon is a Thirty-something-year-old blogger from Mauritius who is currently studying for a Master’s degree in chemical and processing Engineering at the University of Eldoret in Kenya. Read more about him.